Rarely do we find anything agreeable with the likes of Geert Wilders, but his latest statement has a semblance of truth, democracy most certainly in not compatible with the Divine Shariah, and how could it be?
Democracy as a system of government in the first instance is a farce, and we all know it. No government implements laws that are not in its best interests. The needs of the ordinary people are only given credence when election time looms and promises made are quickly forgotten. In short, democracy is a man-made catastrophe, that keeps an capitalist elite in power at the expense of the ordinary man and woman. It subjugates the will of a minority to the whims of the majority and bases legislation on relativistic principles that condemn one day and praise the next.

The Divine Shariah is nothing like this. It is rooted firmly in the immutable text of the Quran and Sunnah, what was deemed wrong 1430yrs ago is still wrong today, majority whims do not take precedence. In opposition to the capitalist system based on riba’a, the Shariah rallies against this unjust exploitation of poverty and installs a system that address the needs of the people without recourse to illegitimate measures.
Notwithstanding the sycophantic whinging of so-called Uncle Tom Muslims who attempt to draw parallels, the scholars of this Ummah are firm on this issue – there is no compatibility; for what fellowship has light with darkness?
For more on this important topic, please listen to:
Democracy in Light of the Quran and Sunnah
Understanding Democracy and its ruling in the Shari’ah.
Alhamdu Lillah. Was Salaatu Was Salaam ‘Ala Rasulillah wa Ba’d.
What is democracy and why it is contradictory to Islam?
In these times many Muslims advocate and participate in the democratic process. They see it as a way to obtain human rights and freedom without bloodshed. It also allows one to choose whomsoever they think can bring about benefit for the Muslims.
Before participating or promoting a slogan or an action it is necessary to know exactly what it is. Allah ta’ala said in his book:
“And do not say what you have no knowledge about.”
And also Imam Al Bukhari said in his authentic collection of narrations: “Chapter: Knowledge comes before statements and actions.” It is upon a Muslim to have knowledge (proofs and evidences)before saying, doing or promoting any activity. Also, it is upon him not to blindfollow anyone in matters of the religion. Allah said in his book: “They took their scholars and monks as dieties other than Allah.” And as narrated from Ibn Abbas “I fear that stones fall upon you from the sky, I say the Messenger said and you say Abu Bakr and Umar said?”
What is Democracy?In order to understand what it is we must look at its origins, its revival and what political scientists themselves have to say about this system.
The basic idea of democracy is self-rule: the word itself comes from the Greek demokratia, meaning rule by the people (Breslin, Hague, Harrop, 20). And it should be noted that the Western Democracies are not Direct Democracies which allow all people to participate in legislative decisions. Rather what is practiced in the Western World is called a liberal democracy where decisions are made by elected politicians who stand for the people (representative government) (Breslin, Hague, Harrop, 21). In other words popular choice determines who the elected officials are and the elected officials decide which policies should and should not be carried out. The citizen therefore doesn’t make any decisions but rather he is reduced to the role of deciding who should make decisions for him. As I would say: Democracy is in reality a popular autocracy meaning that the majority, through their choice, impose their views upon others. and no doubt this is unfair and from injustice.
Democracy unlawful in Islam
From the previous paragraph it is obvious that democracy is an unlawful system of government according to Islam for the following reasons:
(1) Policies and decisions in Islam are determined by the book of Allah and the Sunnah of the Messenger . Allah ta’ala said:
“And if you disagree about anything then its ruling is with Allah.”
And Allah said:
” if you disagree about something return it to the Allah and the Messenger.”
And Allah has said:
“The Rulership is only for Allah.”
And Allah has said:
“Do you see the ones who believe that they believe in what has been sent to you and to those before you and they wish to put their rulings to the Taghuut and they were ordered to disbelieve in it and Shaitaan wants to lead them far astray”
And also Allah has said:
“And whomsoever rules by other than what has revealed they have disbelieved (meaning the one who makes it Halaal, or the same as the Shari’ah or better than the Shari’ah).”
And the verses and ahadeeth dealing with this are many.
In contrast, policies and decisions in a democracy is left up to elected officials in the parliaments whether it corresponds with the book of Allah or not. And these elected officials are voted by the majority. And Allah has said:
“And if you follow most of the people on the earth you would go astray.” And he said: “And you would not find most of them believing in Allah except that he is Mushrik.”
And Allah has praised small numbers as he has said in his book:
“And few of my servants are thankful.”
(2) It is the way of the Kuffar. And it has been proven that democracy is a product of Ancient Greece and Western Europe And there are many Ahadeeth that show that it is prohibited to imitate the Non-Muslims. The Prophet said: “Whomsoever imitates a people is of them.” He also said in a Hadeeth that is narrated in Saheeh Al Bukhari: “You will follow the ways of others, handspan by handspan, until if they were to go into a lizard’s hole you would follow them.” The companions asked: “The Persians and the Romans.” He said: “Who else?”
It is important to remember that Democracy is a Shi’aar or an outward manifestation or system of Western-European nations. And the United States of America in particular preach this form of government in order to obtain sovereignty over nations economically and politically to the point that Woodrow Wilson who was the 16th President of the United States saw himself as morally responsible to spread democracy throughout Latin American nations. And if they didn’t approve American warships would land on their shores.(Dookan, 53)
Similarly, Barack Obama on his website has explicitly stated that if Cuba would like America to take steps to stop the economic embargo, called ‘el bloqueo’ in Spaninsh, then Cuba would have to become democratized (www.barakobama.com: 17/04/09).
Let not one get the idea that I am a supporter of communism since communism requires submission to the nation state. However, what I am trying to show is that instead of Western European nations and the United States claiming lands for the cross, in this day and age they claim lands in the name of democracy.
As for the religion of Islam, one neither submits to the state nor the majority rather one submits to the book of Allah and the Sunnah of the Messenger . As Allah has said:
“And do not die except in a state of Islam.”
And he said:
“Enter Islam wholeheartedly.”
And he said:
“And repent to Allah and submit to him.”
(3) Democracy is a system of injustice as it imposes the view of the majority upon the minority. As for Islam the will of Allah, which governs the universe, governs the system by which mankind lives. And Allah is far removed from oppresion and injustice. Allah has said in his book:
“Verily Allah does not oppress even a mustard seed.”
And he said:
“And your Lord is not oppresive to his servants.”
As is narrated in a Hadeeth Qudsi: “Oh my worshippers I have prevented oppresion upon myself and I have prevented it upon others, therefore do not oppress each other.”
(4) It opens the door to evil and indecency: And Allah has said:
“Verily Allah prevents you from indecent deeds…”
and Allah has said:
“Say: Allah does not order indecency.”
And there are many verses in terms of this. as for democracy it opens the door to fornication, homosexuality and other social ills in the name of freedom and justice for all.
(5) Democracy does not truly guarantee human rights: Rather the rights of citizens are determined by elected officials and the majority who vote these officials. As for Islam there are five major rights of man that the Shariah covers:
(1) The protection of the religion.
(2) The protection of the individual
(3) The protection of one’s intellect.
(4) The right to know one’s descendants.
(5) The right to the protection of one’s wealth (Sayyid Saabiq, 2)
As for Democracy it calls for other than this. It doesn’t protect the religion of Islam as one can worship whomsoever he wishes and even call to the worship of himself. As for the protection of one’s intellect Islam prevents anything that can harm the intellect. As for a democracy one can damage his intellect however he wishes through alcohol usage or drug abuse as occurs in Holand. Also, Islam guarantess the right to know one’s descendants and to this point it has legislated plural marriage and stoning the man and the woman who commit adultery in marriage. As for democracy this right is not fully guaranteed.
(6) It makes everyone the same in deciding upon a government. Hence the righteous and the evil, the straight and the homosexual, the sane and the crazy, the Muslim and the Non-Muslim are the same. And Allah has said: “Do you make the Muslims like the oppressors? ” And also it makes man and woman the same in electing officials when one witness of a man is equal to a woman’s according to the Shari’ah. And when Allah said: “And a man is not like a woman.”
And there are other reasons as to why it contradicts Islam directly. And to this point Ash Shaikh Muqbil said: “Democracy is Kufr because the people are ruled by the people.”
Source:TriniMuslims







